Home Page
|
Calendar
|
Forums
|
Login
|
Feedback on the above article:
( Page 2 of 2.
Page 1
)
Editor (11/05/2022 16:54)
Sorry Jenny. One of the guidelines on exegesis: "When the plain sense makes common sense seek no other sense". I am not persuaded by a series of suppositions to skirt around the plain sense of the text. So we'll just agree to differ. But I will be interested in what others think.
Editor (11/05/2022 22:49)
Regarding the two Sabbaths and the day of crucifixion, I came across this -
https://www.eaec.org/bibleanswers/the_passover_week.htm
And this -
https://www.eaec.org/bibleanswers/passover-week-two-sabbaths.htm
Editor (13/05/2022 12:16)
Roy Thurley of Christian Friends of Israel writes -
>>>
Passover The crucifixion of our Lord took place at the same moment of time as the spotless Passover lamb was being sacrificed, just across town from Gethsemane, at 3pm on Passover eve. He became our sacrifice for all time.
<<<<
https://www.prophecytoday.uk/study/teaching-articles/item/2513-diary-dates.html
Philip Wren (13/05/2022 13:45)
The ADU rule
But because the 15th and 21st days of Nisan and a day or two of Pentecost, and the 10th, 15th, and 22nd of Tisri, were always sabbatical days or days of rest, and it was inconvenient on two Sabbaths together to be prohibited burying their dead and making ready fresh meat, for in that hot region their meat would be apt in two days to corrupt: to avoid these and such like inconveniences, the Jews postponed their months a day, as often as the first day of Tisri, or which is all one, the third of the month of Nisan, was Sunday, Wednesday and Friday: and this rule they called ADU by the letters Aleph, Dalet, Vav, signifying the numbers 1, 4, 6; that is the 1st, 4th and 6th days of the week, which days we call Sunday, Wednesday and Friday.
Page 163 of ‘Observations upon the Prophecies of Daniel and the Apocalypse of John by Sir Isaac Newton
I don't know where Newton got this information I suspect it is buried in some 16th or 17th century volume hidden away in a Cambridge College library. According to Newton there had to be a day separating two Sabbaths. Therefore Matthew 28: 1, having Sabbaths in the plural forces the conclusion that the crucifixion took place on a Wednesday.
Jenny Yates (14/05/2022 11:45) Colin, I agree with the principle (worded slightly differently) that: 'When a straightforward reading of Scripture makes sense as it stands, then don't look for any other sense', but your response to me (11th May), whilst not a direct accusation, implies that I am violating this principle, and 'skirt(ing) around the plain sense of the text'.
I strenuously deny any such suggestion! I provided a perfectly logical way to explain the difference between Luke 23:56 and Mark 16:1 which does not necessitate inserting an ordinary day between the two sabbaths. Other discrepancies between the gospels are far more difficult to explain, e.g. The day of the anointing at Bethany; the day Jesus cleansed the temple; the day the fig tree withered!
I looked at the links you gave. Both put the triumphal entry on Sunday, but if Sunday was 10th Nisan, Wednesday was 13th. That leaves only three days (including the illegal over-night trials) for the inspection of the sacrificial Lamb, instead of the legally required four days - 10th to 14th Nisan.
It is possible to take the 'plain sense' of Scripture over-literally and conclude that believers should hate their families, and even, in some situations, pluck out their eyes or castrate themselves! (As Origen did!) Clearly, Jesus was using idioms.
Jonathan Sarfati, a Messianic Jew who works with Creation Ministries, says the 'three days and three nights' is simply an idiom, and not to be taken literally. He even opts for the crucifixion being on a Friday. He emphasizes the Jewish way of counting days, where even a small part of a day counts as one day; e.g., if a baby boy is born only a few minutes before sundown, that still counts as the first day, when calculating the day for his circumcision on the 8th day.
https://creation.com/easter-and-good-friday-questions-and-answers
I don't accept Sarfati's conclusion about Friday, because in no way does that allow for three nights, but a Thursday crucifixion does - Thursday and Friday nights, and part/most of Saturday night. Philip Wren's quote from Sir Isaac Newton is interesting, but I can't quite fathom out what he means by 'the Jews postponed their months a day'.
Editor (18/06/2024 18:07) I have appended a PDF file which gathers together five charts (all from different sources) covering the different (Wed/Thur/Fri) views of when Jesus was crucified.
See -
https://christianstogether.net/Publisher/file.aspx?id=355808
Editor (20/04/2025 12:29)
When Jesus Christ rode down the Mount of Olives, entering the city of Jerusalem, everyone looked for Him to turn right, and make His way to the Antonio Fortress, where the Roman occupation authority was garrisoned.
Surely this Leader, this Messiah, this Saviour, this Christ, would rescue Israel from foreign rule – but no.
Jesus turned left, making His royal way to the Temple.
The Temple, the church of the day, was so corrupt, commercial, and prayerless, that Christ took steps to cleanse it from everything that should not have been there.
This was holy love, agape love, in action – nothing soft, flabby, or woolly here!
Those in charge were robbing those who had gathered to worship and pray.
The Temple was intended to be a ‘house of prayer’.
Jesus Christ had come into this world primarily to deal with sin, and with sin He would deal.
Within the week He had given His sacrificial life, and shed His precious blood, to wash people from their sin.
It was Passover, and Jesus Christ is our Passover Lamb.
The donkey on which He rode had never been broken in – His very presence seemed to tame that wild untamed beast – what a lesson.
The wild activities of the Temple demanded something quite different.
The very presence of God can transform all kinds of situations, as can the presence of a servant of God.
Some are pleased and blessed, whilst others rebel and plan to crucify.
When Jesus saw the city of Jerusalem, He wept. His longing and desire was to see people coming to Him, so that He could keep people safe – as a hen gathers her chicks under her wings – “but you were not willing!”
Are you? How willing are you?
Sandy Shaw
("Nairnshire Telegraph" column of 9 years ago)
Editor (20/04/2025 13:00)
>>>>>> quote >>>>>>
only in A.D. 30 did the Essene Passover Eve fall 1 day before the Jewish Passover Eve. In all other years the Essene Passover Eve fell in a different week or fell after (not before) the Jewish Passover.
Consequently, A.D. 30 is the only year in which Jesus and His disciples could observe the Essene Passover exactly one day before the Jews and Pharisees etc. observe the Jewish Passover, and hence A.D. 30 is the only year in which Jesus could both observe Passover in the upper room and then Himself be the sacrificial Passover Lamb of God the following day on Jewish Passover.
No other year satisfies all the criteria to harmonize the gospel Passion Week accounts, and hence A.D. 30 stands alone as the only "fit" for the year of crucifixion.
The differences in which day of the week Passover was observed between the Essenes and the Jews (Pharisees, Sadducees, etc.) is due to their different practices in starting their respective annual calendars. The Fourmilab Calendar Converter determines Hebrew dates according to the Jewish method and Hillel II rules. But that same converter does not compute Essene dates.
It is now generally recognized that prior to the crucifixion of Jesus, there were Essenes in Jerusalem, the "upper room" was likely located in an Essene quarter of Jerusalem, the Essenes were the likely inhabitants of Qumran, and the Essene/Qumran calendar was a 364 day solar calendar at odds with the calendrics of the Sanhedrin..
<<<< end quote <<<<<<
https://theos-sphragis.info/essene_passover_dates.html
Editor (20/04/2025 16:56)
The question has sometimes been asked:
"Why did Jesus seem to tarry in respect of the delay in reaching Lazarus on his death".
An AI response to the question states:
>>>>> Rabbinic literature and later Jewish mystical thought contain the idea that the soul hovers near the body for three days after death, hoping to return, and only departs completely when the body begins to decompose and change color.
This is reflected in midrashic sources such as Genesis Rabbah 100: "For three days the soul returns to the grave, thinking that it will return [to the body]; when, however, it sees that the color of its face has changed, it goes away and leaves it". This notion explains why the story of Lazarus in the New Testament emphasizes he had been dead for four days—signaling he was truly and irreversibly dead according to contemporary Jewish belief.<<<<
This would counter any suggestion from Jesus' Jewish enemies that Lazarus hadn't really died and accordingly there we no miracle in his coming back to life.
If all this is indeed the case then it would add weight to the fact that the sign of Jonah (3 days and 3 nights) would be validating feature of Christ's death and resurrection.
Boswell (23/04/2025 16:50)
I would like to recommend Dr Baruch Korman’s article “The Passover that changed the World” - loveisrael.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/Passover_Changed_World.pdf
The article gives explanations of seemingly conflicting statements in the Passover account of the four Gospels. Baruch teaches the Bible verse by verse ‘live’ from the original languages and from a Jewish perspective and context. It anyone notices any error/s he may have made in this writings, or videos, he would be more than happy to hear from them with details of the passages of Scripture which reveal his error/s.
( Page 2 of 2.
Page 1
)
From:
Comment:
© 2026 Christians Together
High Accessibility Version
. (
Full Graphics Version
)