Home Page
|
Calendar
|
Forums
|
Login
|
Feedback on the above article:
( Page 2 of 4.
Page 1
Page 3
Page 4
)
Skeptic (Guest) (05/08/2014 21:50)
This is a very interesting and deep subject; Revival? Can it happen, or indeed has it ever happened?
From my research, I have learnt that Duncan Campbell (like Martin LLoyd Jones, believed in the baptism of the Holy Spirit as an experience subsequent to conversion).
I cannot accept this, as such would be contrary to very plain Bible teaching. I cannot,therefore understand why otherwise very sound men raised in the Reformed Faith would depart into the realms of unbiblical and extremely dangerous experiential theology?
Maybe some erudite believers on this forum may shed some light on this? From my limited research into this phenomena, I may add that it is very difficult, well nigh impossible to confirm if what was reported to have happened on that island was a "move of God".
John Miller (07/08/2014 14:32) "Skeptic" I agree with you. Scripture teaches very plainly that we are sealed with the spirit when we believed. I do believe that if a believer is being used of God for some specific purpose or service and is a suitable vessel for His empowerment, he may be conscious of the the power of God's Holy Spirit in a very distinct way.
I believe that there are many scriptures that are examples of this, which explain the expression "being filled with the Spirit. We must always, of course, understand that God does not give His Spirit by measure (John 3:34).
John Miller (07/08/2014 14:34)
The title of The Spirit should have had a capital letter in the first line of my previous post. I apologise for the error.
Skeptic (Guest) (07/08/2014 21:52)
Thanks John for that, at least I am not on my own!
This "Baptism of the Holy Spirit" AFTER conversion as you seem to suggest is unbiblical-especially as the Pentecostals teach it is accompanied by speaking in tongues etc. If as you say we are "sealed" when we believe, well, then "sealed" means we have the "Spirit of Christ dwelling in us, as Romans 8.9 tells us.
When you say "he may be conscious of the power of God's Holy Spirit in a very distinct way"; does the Bible actually teach that? I would suggest that statement is verging on Pentecostal/Charismatic experiential theology?
But, again thanks for your reply.
Looking at the article again, do you believe that two 80 plus year old ladies were on their knees for 5-6 hours? If I am on my knees for much more than ten minutes I get cramp, and I am nearer half their age!
Penny Lee (08/08/2014 12:20)
Yes, I believe these two 80-year old ladies most likely were on their knees to this degree. I had an aunt who was on her knees in the middle of the night during the coldest day of the year, in an unheated house, praying for me while I slept oblivious many miles away. She awoke during the night with a strong feeling that 'something was wrong' with me and actually got up, knelt by her bed and prayed specifically for me for at least half an hour. She was 92 at the time!
I also knew as I grew up not to disturb her when we arrived at her house which she shared with her sisters, as she spent time reading the Bible and praying in one room for hours every day. I wonder how much good was done due to the time this dear lady spent in prayer. Instead of being sceptical that some people can, and do, pray to this extent, perhaps we should be trying to improve our own dedication to serious prayer. I now pray on my knees twice a day following a most awful year where everything just seemed to go wrong and almost finished with my husband's death. This is what finally made me take prayer more seriously and I also pray on every occasion for revival for the area where I live, so that's twice a day. I think I've finally got the message that revival such as is described above doesn't happen until Christians dedicate themselves to serious, continued and heartfelt prayer for others, and it may go on for many years. It may be even after the person's death before the results of their prayers are seen. However, they will be seen because God has promised He will reward such earnest and dedicated intercessory prayer. So I'll keep praying, and if I don't see revival in my lifetime then I have every confidence it will still happen sometime in the future.
Editor (08/08/2014 15:44)
"And so I tell you, every sin and blasphemy will be forgiven men, but the blasphemy against the Spirit will not be forgiven.
Anyone who speaks a word against the Son of Man will be forgiven, but anyone who speaks against the Holy Spirit will not be forgiven, either in this age or in the age to come". (Matt 12:31-32)
I'm not sure what it would take for a believer to commit the 'unforgiveable sin' but (personally) I wouldn't want to get anywhere near that possibility.
The closest that I have ever seen someone get to it (I think) was a minister who denounced from the pulpit the 'manifestations' during the Lewis Revival. During that sermon an elderly lady who had come to know the Lord in the midst of that time broke down in grief and wept in the pew behind me at what she was hearing.
I feel that believers need to be very careful in
(a) defining how the Spirit works (and will work) in any particular situation or a believer's life and
(b) denying any post-conversion experience of the Holy Spirit
(c) seeking (as if we could) to push the Holy Spirit into a box shaped by our own personal/denominational theology and/or experience.
Charles G. Finney was "powerfully converted in the morning of the 10th Oct. 1821". Subsequently he "received overwhelming baptisms of the Holy Ghost, that went through me, as it seemed to me, body and soul". (Note the time-lapse between 'conversion' and 'baptisms'; with the latter described in the plural.)
This experience is far from exceptional.
For recommended reading I would suggest:
Lewis Revival:
'Channel of Revival' (A biography of Duncan Campbell by Andrew A. Woolsley
'Sounds from Heaven' by Colin and Mary Peckham (Mary was a product of the Lewis Revival
'When God Came Down' by John Ferguson
'Skye Revivals' by Steve Taylor (the religious awakening on Skye between 1800 and 1860)
'Revival Man' by George Mitchell (story of revivals amongst fishermen and God's use of Jock Troup)
'Glory in the Glen' by Tom Lennie (A History of Evangelical Revivals in Scotland 1880 - 1940)
'The Cambuslang Revival' by Arthur Fawcett (The Scottish Evangelical Revival of the eighteenth century)
'The Year of Grace' by William Gibson (A history of the 1859 Ulster Revival)
'...if my people' by William Fleming (1958 revival centred in the mid-Antrim village of Ahoghill, Northern Ireland)
'The Revival We Need' by Oswald J. Smith (in his foreword Rev. Jonathan Goforth writes: "Had I the wealth of a millionaire I would put [the book] in every Christian home on this continent and confidently look for a revival which would sweep round the world".)
Starting in 2009 I published a series of articles by a dear brother and good friend (Rev. Alex Muir; now in glory) on the subject of 'Revival'. The first of these (with links to the others in the series) can be found at -
http://www.christianstogether.net/Articles/164548/Christians_Together_in/Christian_Life/Revivals_in_the.aspx
A tribute to Alex and be found at -
http://www.christianstogether.net/Articles/190668/Christians_Together_in/Around_the_Region/Wider_News/Rev_Alex_Muir.aspx
I have all the above-mentioned books in my 'library' and if anyone wants further information on them then please be in touch by e-mail. (Please do not leave one-to-one personal messages on this, or any other, thread. Such postings just create unhelpful and unwelcome 'clutter'.)
PS. Please note (those to whom this applies) I am increasingly running out of patience with regular posters who persist in remaining anonymous. The invitation is either to (a) register with the site or (b) e-mail me privately.
So doing will impart an honest credibility which anonymous postings otherwise lack.
Skeptic (Guest) (09/08/2014 23:21)
(Please do not leave one-to one personal messages on this or any other, thread. Such postings just create unhelpful and unwelcome 'clutter'.)
Then, by the grace of God, if you are not interested in anything other than your own narrow theology, why don't you just make your website available to members only? By this means you will attract 'Christians' to your own liking and none other? While your website is open to all and sundry I see no lawful reason why I cannot comment here.
Is an anonymous comment any less valid than one of your members? Many are uncertain who the author of Hebrews is, is this book less valid?
With the greatest of respect, your reasoning is very shallow.
Does the name David Stewart mean anything to you?
May God bless your website.
Editor (11/08/2014 09:29)
Skeptic, If you are serious when you say: "May God bless your website", one way that you can be involved in the answer is to pray that my time will no longer be wasted with those who wish to use the response facility to pursue personal vendettas and who do not have have the Christian integrity to make themselves know.
Skeptic (Guest) (11/08/2014 22:26)
Editor,
I sincerely apologise to you if I am causing you any unnecessary stress. I have no personal vendetta whatsoever. My only 'vendetta' as it were is to contend for the truth.
The very fact that you believe Charles G Finney is a man of God, and I believe the exact opposite shows how opposed we are in Biblical theology. I believe Finney was an apostate, or worse, and yet you hold him in such high and glowing terms.
The very fact that you erased my comment should sound alarm bells to your members.
Truly, I pray that God would make much use of your website, of course I do-Romans 8.28.
Editor (12/08/2014 12:30)
Dear Skeptic, It is not 'stress', but just the time it takes to respond to messages like the one you have just left. I do not want to have these threads taken up with one-to-one dialogue; neither do I want them (as I have mentioned before) to be used for 'personal vendettas' (as some anonymous posters continue to do).
If you are earnesty to 'contend for truth' then I would kindly ask you to register with the site.
Many thanks,
Ed.
PS Whatever you think of Finney, please note my comment "This [Finney's] experience is far from exceptional throughout the ages and around the world.
If you want to discuss post-conversion experiences of the Holy Spirit then (as a registered site member) you would be welcome so to do.
( Page 2 of 4.
Page 1
Page 3
Page 4
)
From:
Comment:
© 2026 Christians Together
High Accessibility Version
. (
Full Graphics Version
)