Home Page
|
Calendar
|
Forums
|
Login
|
Feedback on the above article:
( Page 3 of 4.
Page 1
Page 2
Page 4
)
Extremely sceptical (Guest) (12/08/2014 17:23)
/>Charles G. Finney was "powerfully converted in the morning of the 10th Oct. 1821".
I don't doubt it.
But converted to what?
That is the $64000 question
(Guest) (12/08/2014 18:11)
Charles G. Finney was "powerfully converted in the morning of the 10th Oct. 1821".
I don't doubt it.
But converted to what?
That is the $64000 question
/
It's all academic now.
(Guest) (12/08/2014 22:15)
It's all academic now.
That's the problem - isn't it?
Christendom is full of people with an academic knowledge of Christ who, not unnaturally have an af'Finney'ty, with those who likewise have an academic knowledge of Christ (and call themselves brothers in Christ), but alas.......
There's more to true Christianity than 'Truth'.
Truth has a moral/spiritual neutrality - it can be used for righteous purpose or bad, which is why Christ said:
God is a Spirit, and His worshippers must worship Him in spirit and in truth....John 4/24.
Academic knowledge of Christ is no gauge of the genuineness of anyone's faith.
Skeptic (Guest) (13/08/2014 12:02)
Editor,
It is not too difficult to know (to those whom God has given the eyes to see, at least) what side of the theological fence you sit on. This controversy (so-called) has been raging throughout the church age, at least more so since the Reformation and the balmy days of the Puritans.
But I DON'T want to discuss "post-conversion experiences of the Holy Spirit"!
If someone says "God told me" etc., well then that statement and many similar, nullifies any discussion, especially if what is said doesn't agree with Scripture, can you not see that? It may well be that that "elderly lady broke down in grief", but whatever does that prove? The conversation is going nowhere if we are going into the realms of experiology.(a new word?)
Having said all this; what I have just said is pertinent to the heading of this article, whether you like what I say or not? So I cannot see the point of deleting what I say and indeed some others here. I am a believer, so are you, but we others who visit here disagree with some rather fundamental matters, especially soteriology, signs and wonders etc...
(Guest) (13/08/2014 12:31) @ Skeptic,
With respect, being a believer (in Christ) doesn't necessarily make a person a truly 'born again' Christian.
And on the matter of charismatic/pentecostal manifestations, I believe that they are, just that, MANifestions - sired by Satan and implanted into the womb of man's very receptive, and very carnal, and very fertile emotionalism
Skeptic (Guest) (13/08/2014 12:35) Guest,
That WASN'T the inference, having said that, the Editor IS a believer, unless he says otherwise. We all know the verses in Matthew 7.22 that say "Lord, Lord have we not prophesied...."?
John Miller (13/08/2014 16:38)
I think that some of the contributions to this thread are very unwise to say the least. Anonymity does not help and sniping from a hidden position is not spiritual warfare according to biblical teaching or standards. The writer of the Epistle to the Hebrews would have been known to those who received it so that reasoning is not helpful.
In relation to the baptism of the Holy Spirit, as with all subjects that bear on our Christian faith we must turn to the scriptures for help in our understanding.
It is specifically mentioned in Mark 1:8, Luke 3:16, John 1:33 (Acts 11:16), 1 Cor.12:13. In Acts 10 we have a record of an experience in a Gentile company similar to the Pentecost experience of Jewish believers.
Peter's sermons at Pentecost and at Caesarea were the fulfillment of the Lord's gift of the keys of the Kingdom and a sign of the Holy Spirit's ratification of Christ's words. In 1 Cor.12:13 we must observe the word "all" and the experience is clearly simultaneous with "drinking of one Spirit" which refers to the gift of the Spirit. Paul elsewhere tells us that we are sealed with the Spirit "when we believe".
I do not deny that the Holy Spirit of God can use suitably prepared men of God to minister in a very distinctive way in His power as and when He pleases with the sole purpose of bringing glory to the name of Jesus, but there is no biblical authority for claiming that the baptism of the Holy Spirit is distinct from conversion and the experience of being born again. It is not presented in scripture as being some subsequent experience.
If 1 Cor.12:13 is the truth of God that claim must be false.
(Guest) (13/08/2014 17:29)
@ Skeptic
The Pope and his worshippers, together with countless others of different denominations claim to be 'believers' - but that does not (necessarily) make them so
As Matthew 7/21-23 will confirm 'knowing' Christ is not life giving/changing, it is being 'known by Him' which is life giving/changing.
(Guest) (13/08/2014 17:35)
@ John Miller
You said, 'sniping from a hidden position is not spiritual warfare'
And I would respond 'and nether is character assasinationlltinue from open positions
Skeptic (Guest) (13/08/2014 19:55)
Guest,
I don't think you fully understand me, a believer does not necessarily mean a saved person, we only have to read James 2.19 to know that?
As to the book of Hebrews, I believe it was written by Paul. Nevertheless, he decided (or rather the Holy Spirit did) not to sign it. Just as I decide (within my rights not to sign this communication) God knows all our thoughts and ways-"in Him we have our movement and being".
I don't see why I have to be coerced into becoming a member-for whatever reason? The Editor can close off his site to non-members should he choose to do so, I will always be polite and courteous. But regardless of this, I know that many will disagree with me, so I cannot see the point of becoming a member of a site that is heavily biased in favour of Pentecostal theology.
I agree with much of what Mr Miller says, but, I don't like his use of the word "distinctive", this would seem to me to give way to a "God told me so" spirit. I certainly do reject the Pentecostal/Charismatic heresy of which men like Charles G. Finney did much to promote.
( Page 3 of 4.
Page 1
Page 2
Page 4
)
From:
Comment:
© 2026 Christians Together
High Accessibility Version
. (
Full Graphics Version
)